EnforceMintz

Our 2025 edition of EnforceMintz reflects on health care enforcement trends, predicts how health care enforcement may evolve, and offers practical guidance about what these trends and predictions mean for health care providers, payors, and other stakeholders.

Government scrutiny of value-based care (VBC) health care delivery models is expected to increase as VBC adoption grows. In 2024, the DOJ announced a large FCA settlement with a VBC primary care practice, and HHS’s Office of Inspector General issued a Special Fraud Alert focusing on VBC business arrangements.

In 2024, the HHS Office of Inspector General added the University of Colorado Health d/b/a/ UCHealth, an established provider, to the Heightened Scrutiny list after UCHealth settled an FCA case for $23 million, without an admission of wrongdoing.

In 2024, the FTC and state attorneys general pursued various theories of liability against a diverse array of entities offering health care or health care–related services, and employed numerous different enforcement tools and partnerships. We expect that the agencies will continue developing these strategies in 2025.

In 2024, the COVID-19 Fraud Enforcement Task Force, in conjunction with five COVID Fraud Enforcement Strike Forces and other government agencies, has resolved many significant criminal and civil pandemic fraud cases. More civil pandemic fraud enforcement actions and continuing criminal actions are expected in 2025.

Our 2025 edition of EnforceMintz reflects on health care enforcement trends, predicts how health care enforcement may evolve, and offers practical guidance about what these trends and predictions mean for health care providers, payors, and other stakeholders.

Over the past two years, the Department of Justice has actively incentivized companies to voluntarily self-disclose potential civil and criminal violations. This article explores the DOJ’s new policies, the benefits of self-disclosure, and the challenges companies face in complying with these initiatives.

In 2024, federal courts issued significant False Claims Act decisions for the health care and life sciences industries. These decisions further develop the FCA scienter standard addressed by the Supreme Court in its 2023 SuperValu decision and reexamine the constitutionality of the FCA’s qui tam provisions. A circuit split on the interpretation of “causation” for FCA suits based on alleged violations of the Anti-Kickback Statute (AKS) has also emerged.

In 2024, DOJ and the OIG expanded telehealth enforcement beyond traditional telefraud schemes, addressing compliance with state corporate practice and telehealth-specific billing codes. Two cases, including the first criminal telemedicine prosecution, signal a trend of heightened regulatory scrutiny for the maturing telehealth industry.

Following the Supreme Court’s decision in Securities and Exchange Commission v. Jarkesy, holding that the Seventh Amendment entitles defendants to a jury trial when the SEC seeks to impose civil monetary penalties for a securities fraud violation, parties are starting to assert Jarkesy-based arguments in appealing administrative actions of the Department of Health and Human Services.

As opioid-related enforcement efforts continued across the opioid supply chain in 2024, the government pursued criminal charges in two matters that resulted in significant settlements. Additionally, a number of recent cases against pharmacies involve a common theory of liability based on the Controlled Substances Act, which served as the basis for civil liability under the False Claims Act.

In 2024, DOJ resolved several noteworthy False Claims Act cases against hospitals and health systems, obtaining numerous large recoveries in cases where Stark Law and federal Anti-Kickback Statute violations served as a predicate for FCA claims.

In 2024, the Department of Justice ramped up cybersecurity enforcement under the Civil Cyber-Fraud Initiative (CCFI), targeting entities that failed to safeguard PHI and PII in federally funded contracts. Key cases highlight trends in False Claims Act litigation and underscore the importance of cybersecurity compliance heading into 2025.

In 2024, the Department of Justices and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services intensified enforcement in Medicare Advantage and Part D, with a focus on risk adjustment audits and Star Ratings disputes. Key developments, including litigation and regulatory changes, signal heightened scrutiny for MAOs, PDP Sponsors, and their vendors in 2025.